Saturday, September 12, 2026

Best Low Fantasy Books for 5th grade

Looking for summer reading recommendations from real, live people? My 5th graders each compiled a #BestBookList, which could have an overall theme or not. You can see all of their recommendations at #BestBookList. For individual book recommendations, check out our  #iLoveMG posts. If you are looking for younger readers, #3rdfor3rd features recommendations from when I taught third grade.

Top 5 Low Fantasy Books

Recommended by IviƩ


  • The Land of Stories is about twins Alex and Bailey, trying to rid the story world from evil. 
  • In Percy Jackson, a boy with ADHD and Dyslexia is somehow dealing with Greek gods and regular life.
  • Harry Potter is about an orphan that just happens to be a wizard. 
  • Keeper of the Lost Cities is about a girl named Sophie, who learns she isn’t a human. She’s . . . an elf. 
  • In Nic Blake and the Remarkables, she is an exile living in the unremarkable world instead of the Remarkable world. Everything changes when she realizes, her dad has been charged with being a criminal. 
All these books can take you on a journey that will have you turning pages and not stopping. They will take you on a ride . . . if you accept the challenge.

Click here for all of our #BestBooks posts or click #iLoveMG for individual book recommendations. What is your favorite middle grade book for 5th grader?

Saturday, August 29, 2026

Three Series I Could Not Put Down

Looking for summer reading recommendations from real, live people? My 5th graders each compiled a #BestBookList, which could have an overall theme or not. You can see all of their recommendations at #BestBookList. For individual book recommendations, check out our  #iLoveMG posts. If you are looking for younger readers, #3rdfor3rd features recommendations from when I taught third grade.

Three Series I Could Not Put Down

Recommended by Arlo


  • Spy School is a series filled with action and excitement. It stars Ben Rippley who was invited to the Academy of Espionage. 
  • Restart is about a middle schooler named Chase who loses his memory. He was previously a bully. Will he beat his old reputation, or will people forever hate him? 
  • Wings of Fire is a series with many arcs. The first arc is about five dragonets tasked to stop the Great War.

    Click here for all of our #BestBooks posts or click #iLoveMG for individual book recommendations. What is your favorite middle grade book for 5th graders?

Saturday, August 8, 2026

5 Books I Recommend about Acceptance and Stuff

Who can pass up a best book list about acceptance ... and stuff?

My 5th graders each compiled a #BestBookList, which could have an overall theme or not. You can see all of their recommendations at #BestBookList. For individual book recommendations, check out our  #iLoveMG posts. If you are looking for younger readers, #3rdfor3rd features recommendations from when I taught third grade.

5 Books I Recommend about Acceptance and Stuff

Recommended by Delia


  • Starfish is a wonderfully written novel in verse about a girl named Ellie who struggles with fat shaming. Throughout the book she learns to accept herself just the way she is. This book is amazing and would totally recommend. 
  • A Season Most Unfair is about a girl named Tic, she learned the trade of candle making for her whole life, but replaced by a “proper” apprentice. She eventually comes to terms with this and finds a new trade that girl’s can learn. I loved this historical book about finding purpose no matter who you are. 
  • The Other Boy is about a trans-masc boy named Shane, who struggles with telling his friends and baseball team about his past. And struggles with other’s opinions throughout the book, especially when his secret get leaked. Overall, I loved the book, topic, and little comics scattered through the book. 
  • Sweep is a beautiful book about a girl named Nan. Nan was a climber raised by a kind sweep, but after his mysterious disappearance, she was bought by a cruel man named Mr. Crudd. Throughout the book, Nan will struggle with hiding her monster from the outside world. I loved the sad, yet happy ending. 
  • Unstuck is a great book about a girl named Lyla, when she is assigned with writing a story for class she is very excited. She had been making a story in her head for years, but when it came to actually write it down, she feels stuck. Throughout the book, Lyla comes to peace with all the problems in her life and takes it one step at a time writing her story. I loved this book (and cover design) and all the helpful tips for anyone who needs to be unstuck.

    Click here for all of our #BestBooks posts or click #iLoveMG for individual book recommendations. What is your favorite middle grade book for 5th graders?

Saturday, July 18, 2026

All-Time Best Graphic Novels for 5th Grade

If your fifth graders are anything like mine, they ADORE graphic novels. 5th grader Rory has you set with her top recommendations.

Looking for summer reading recommendations from real, live people? My 5th graders each compiled a #BestBookList, which could have an overall theme or not. You can see all of their recommendations at #BestBookList. For individual book recommendations, check out our  #iLoveMG posts. If you are looking for younger readers, #3rdfor3rd features recommendations from when I taught third grade.

All-Time Best Graphic Novels

Recommended by Rory


  • El Deafo: El Deafo is about Cece, a young girl who is deaf. 
  • The New Girl: Lia is a 12-year-old Romanian immigrant adjusting to life in Canada. Lia has highs and lows. But even in those lows her friends are there for her. 
  • The Babysitters Club: Kristy has a Idea: Let’s start a babysitting business with her friends. 
  • Smile: Riana is just a normal sixth grader until one day where she races her friends Kelli and Melissa to her house but falls and loses 2 teeth. 
  • The Roller Girl: Twelve-Year-Old Astrid use too do everything with her best friend Nicole but now Astrids not sure how there friendship is the same as before. Astrid is going to Roller Camp. Which Nicole may be going too.

    Click here for all of our #BestBooks posts or click #iLoveMG for individual book recommendations. What is your favorite middle grade book for 5th graders?

Saturday, May 23, 2026

Favorite Middle Grade Dystopian Books

You might think of dystopia as the purvey of YA (young adult), but there are a lot of excellent dystopian books for middle grade readers too. This bookmark, featuring six middle grade dystopian books, is one of the most popular in my classroom library! You can download a full page of bookmarks here.

You can see the whole set of bookmark blog posts here: Book Recommendation Bookmarks. If you want recommendations from my fifth graders themselves, check out #iLoveMG for individual books and Best Book Lists for their end-of-year favorites.

Favorite Dystopian Middle Grade Stories


Alone (series) by Megan E. Freeman. When a sleepover goes awry, Maddie finds herself alone in a town that has been entirely evacuated. She must learn to survive on her own when all the trappings of modern society have stopped working. This fast-paced novel-in-verse is gripping and thrilling. (When I read this aloud to my fifth graders, they begged for just one more poem every time.) Book two, Away, presents an alternate perspective on the same events, and my students are eagerly awaiting book three!

Cleo Porter and the Body Electric by Jake Burt. A pandemic has forced everyone to survive in their own separate, compartmentalized units. But when Cleo mistakenly receives a stranger's package, she knows the recipients life might be in danger. What she does not know is what challenges she will face in her efforts to return the package... and perhaps uncover the secrets behind their enforced isolation.

Outside by Jennifer L. Holm (Newbery winning author). Razzi and her friends have lived their entire lives inside the Refuge, fearful of the Outside that recently resulted in the death of her friend Ollie. But an encounter with a stray dog has Razzi questioning things she never has before. Can she handle the answers she uncovers?

Dark Life by Kat Falls. [Student review by Owen.] The water level is rising and there is only one square mile of land left so some people are living in the sea. There is a guy named Ty, and he meets and girl named Gemma from the land. Outlaws attack their home underwater, and they have to catch the outlaws. It was a good book. I thought there was a good mix between violence and mystery. So if you like dystopian books then you should read this book I rate it a 4 out of 5 stars.

Among the Hidden (series) by Margaret Peterson Haddix. [Student review by Jack.] Margret Peterson Haddix has outdone herself with this series. Among the Hidden is about a boy who has to stay hidden since he is a third child, if he doesn’t the population police will come after him. One day he sees a girl’s face in the window of a house where two children already live, Now he has found another shadow child like himself. The other shadow child, Jen, has a plan to make the third children free, but it is very dangerous and possibly deadly. 

Personally, I think this is a great book since it slowly starts to get more exciting, and then Wham! There's the surprise ending. If you don’t mind a or like a very sad ending, with quite a plot twist, and if you like series, then this is the book for you! I would give this book five out of five stars because of all these things! Now go read this über exciting book!

The City of Ember (series) by Jeanne DuPrau. [Student review by Louis] The City of Ember by Jeanne DuPrau, is a dystopian or post-apocalyptic fiction book. The book is centered around two main characters, Lina and Doon. It is about a city where the sky is pitch black, and the only thing stopping all light in the city from vanishing forever is a river and a machine that generates electricity from the flow of the river. But during the events of the book the lights are starting to flicker. 

I think that this design of the post-apocalyptic world is an extremely creative idea. One of the ongoing themes of this book and others in this series is how they managed to make suspense and excitement with a completely non-violent story. 

This book is not like very many other books I have read, as it has an original theme and setting, but if you like books with lots of suspense and several twists and turns along the way, the City of Ember is one of my favorites in the category. In conclusion this is one of my favorite books that I have read and I would highly recommend it to anyone who wants a mystery-ish story with a great plot and lots of suspense.


What other dystopian middle grade books would you include? Share in the comments below!


Looking for more middle grade? Check out #iLoveMG for all my 5th graders' book reviews or Best Book Lists for their end-of-year favorites.



Tuesday, May 12, 2026

Favorite Neurodiverse Middle Grade Stories

There are a ton of wonderful middle grade books coming out that feature neurodiverse characters. In an effort to share more books with my 5th graders, I've been creating bookmarks that feature six books on a single theme. You can download a full page of bookmarks here.

You can see the whole set of bookmark posts here: Book Recommendation Bookmarks. If you want recommendations from my fifth graders themselves, check out #iLoveMG for individual books and Best Book Lists for their end-of-year favorites.

Favorite Neurodiverse Middle Grade Stories


Get a Grip, Vivy Cohen! by Sarah Kapit. This engaging baseball story is written as a series of letters between Vivy, an autistic 11-year-old, and her professional baseball player pen pal. This book is a great fit for kids who love sports, endearing characters, and a big dose of determination! 

Honestly Elliott by Gillian McDunn. (Student review by Marcus) This book is about a kid named Elliot who has ADHD and can’t concentrate on anything except cooking. When he gets his anger out by throwing baseballs at a window he has to face consequences! He has the money that he needs saved up but he wants to go to a cooking camp with that money! What will he do? When he gets a chance in school to sell stuff at a local marketplace he teams up with a unlikely friend to get enough money to pay his dad back and still be able to go to cooking camp.

BenBee and the Teacher Griefer by K. A. Holt. This novel-in-verse (and several other formats) features the point of view of four different students who are stuck in summer school. Their teacher helps them see their own strengths as they show her the benefits of video games! Perfect for all readers, as everyone can find a way to relate. 

The Miscalculations of Lightning Girl by Stacey McAnulty. A lightning strike might have turned Lucy's brain into a super-genius at math, but it might not have prepared her for her greatest challenge... middle school! This is a highly entertaining book about embracing what makes us unique and celebrating friendship.

How to Make Friends with the Sea by Tanya Guererro. Moving to the Philippines has given Pablo even more things to fear, and his mother seems intent on adding to his list. But when his mother brings in Chiqui, an orphaned girl with a cleft lip, Pablo learns new ways to discover his courage.

Good Different by Meg Eden Kuyatt [a Schneider Family Book Award Honor]. Selah has relied on her rules for being normal in order to mask her own feelings and true self. But when an outburst at school exposes more than she intended, she has to learn how to love all of herself and help her school to love all of themselves too. The novel-in-verse format makes this book particularly emotional and accessible.  


What other neurodiverse middle grade books would you include? Share in the comments below!


Looking for more middle grade? Check out #iLoveMG for all my 5th graders' book reviews or Best Book Lists for their end-of-year favorites.

Saturday, January 24, 2026

Mock Sibert Winners 2026 #SibertSmackdown

The ALA Youth Media Awards are coming on Monday! (Livestream here on Mon 1/26/26 at 10 am CT.) This is the Super Bowl of the kidlit world, when many of the major book awards are announced including the Newbery and Caldecott Awards. Every year, I try to have my students participate in at least one mock awards vote.

The past few years we've enjoyed Melissa Stewart's Sibert Smackdown. The Sibert Medal is for informational fiction (nonfiction), and each year Melissa shares her slate of top books for schools to host their own Mock Sibert voting. In coordination with our school librarian, my 5th graders have spent the past month reading, analyzing, and discussing their favorites among this year's choices.


We added four additional books to Melissa's list in order to get a full slate of 16. Our third graders participated in a bracket-style challenge, while my 5th graders investigated all 16.

We read aloud different books with each class, and it was interesting to see how much the voting was swayed by books we read aloud vs. books the students read and discussed in pairs. 

And the Winners Are ... 





Our honor books were...


In my second class, the winner was Black Mambas: The World's First All-Woman Anti-Poaching Unit written and photographed by Kelly Crull!

The honors books were...
  • Tomatoes on Trial: The Fruit v. Vegetable Showdown written by Lindsay H. Metcalf and illustrated by Edwin Fotheringham.
    • Back in December, we used the Mock Trial lesson on Lindsay's web site to stage our own Fruit vs. Vegetable showdown, and the kids really had a blast with it! (Spoiler alert: in both our classes, Team Fruit won, contradicting the historical results.) 

Third Grade Bracket Results


Thanks so much to third grade teacher Carol for sharing her student's bracket results. She had each of her classes complete one side of the bracket, then both class's top choice book went head-to-head in a dramatic final vote. 



I love how you can see their careful discussions and tallying across different categories of analysis: information, writing, text features, backmatter, illustration, design, and topic. 



Above is example of the worksheet we used in 5th grade. 

And without further delay, the third grade bracket results ...
  • Honor book: Hurricane written and illustrated by Jason Chin

Who are your top choices for the awards this year! Share a guess in the comments below!

Want more of my 5th graders' favorite books? Click here for all of our #iLoveMG posts